Skip to main content

Embedding #OwnVoices into the Definition Essay

Teacher (/ˈtēCHər/) Noun - 1. a person who teachers, especially in school. 2. A person who opens windows for students to explore. 3. A person whose day extends before and beyond the 7am-3pm work day. 4. A perpetual student.

Definition essay is one of the main essay types we teach in English 9 at Horace Greeley. Over the years, the types of definition essays I taught and explored evolved. In the last two years, we explored what it means to be a protagonist using The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams. 

But call it restlessness or boredom or changing with the times, my definition essay was in need of an overhaul. Enter: Stamped by Jason Reynolds, This Book is Anti-Racist by Tiffany Jewell and nearly a dozen different titles from an #OwnVoices unit.

This year, my English 9 team and I are gearing up to teach Stamped for the first time. We talked about starting the year with it but decided talking about systematic racism on the first day of high school might prove overwhelming. Now, as we ready to approach the book in December, we've used activities from This Book is Anti-Racist and a host of other supporting texts. 

Side note: This book is essential reading!

I'm a huge fan of Jewell's book (it was literally my last blog post before my extended hiatus from blogging). What I love most is how it lays out definitions to an assortment of words including, but not limited to privilege, anti-racism, anti-bias, oppression, history, race, ethnicity and dominant culture. 

Early on, I wanted students to become familiar with this vocabulary; however, as I read (and continue to read) many anti-racist texts, I often find conflicting information. What Jewell says about privilege doesn't quite match with Reynolds and Kendi, which doesn't quite match Diangelo's thoughts, etc etc. I was okay with this. To me, these books are sociology texts. They come from unique experiences. These are not sacred texts (Kendi's teaching of queer culture in This Book is Antiracist is particularly egregious), and as educators (and informed readers) we need to be okay with that. I realized, I want students to use the evidence presented to them in texts to help inform their own definitions. 

And so begat the newest iteration of the definition essay.

At this juncture, I've positioned the definition essay as a way of students not just defining a word, but expanding the meaning of the word. As I did with "teacher" up above, it's about evolving the word. To any naysayers, words change and expand meaning over time. They always have and always will. Think of words such as a streak, a tweet, or even a troll. So students are taking some time to look at #OwnVoices poems and short stories to start giving words new and expanded meaning. 

These were the books chosen by students for our #OwnVoices unit

One way I've approached this is by asking students to choose which word (out of a given list) is an exemplar of a given poem (see this handout). The discussion during this time has become rather lively. In Hughes' Merry-Go-Round, I thought many students would go with Discrimination or Oppression. I was surprised as students explained their thoughts that Race or Dominant Culture was the best example. During a discussion of Ambiguity Over the Confederate Flag students focused on other words such as History or Society. 

For many of my students (largely an affluent suburban white population) this has become the first true access point of discussing race and language in a way that feels meaningful. And while some of the groups are quick to concede their word, many are taking all of the information and using other words as "umbrella terms" to help fit everyone's words into a new definition. For 9th graders (most over Zoom and many still struggling to find their voice), this is the first time I've heard them speak up. It's pretty exciting.

Now students are gearing up to define these words in a full definition essay with our #OwnVoices books. I've started to look at different ways to open our essay including (but not limited to) personifying the word ala The Book of Qualities. And as we broaden our scope, I'm sure there is much more to discover.

For the first time in a while I'm feeling hopeful. That as we move closer to Stamped, students will readily engage with the tough conversations we undoubtedly will have. Hopefully (secular god willing), these conversations will allow students to emerge as better critical thinkers. 

Daniel Valentin teaches English 9 and Ethics at Horace Greeley High School. He is currently reading The Black Kids by Christina Hammonds Reed and is listening to Stay Gold by Tobly McSmith. He wants his students to feel empowered through books. Follow him on Twitter @DanielJValentin
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

HyperDocs: Creating Ownership Through Exploration

HyperDocs are here, and the potential for student exploration and engagement seems bountiful. But hold up— Before we delve into the potential, what is a HyperDoc? The short answer is: It's a Google Doc with a variety of links that leads to a number of different tasks. Once students receive this doc, they're free to explore it in any order and any pace of their choosing. But to sum up a HyperDoc as a Google Doc with just a bunch of links would be the equivalent of saying Moby Dick  is a book about a whale. To be so reductive is to miss the point. To see a full HyperDoc Click Here Going Beyond the Workshop Model As an ELA teacher, I'm a workshop model kind of guy. Walk into my class at any given moment, and you know what you will see. The first ten minutes? Reading. The next five to ten minutes? Quick Write. Followed by mini-lessons, workshop time and sharing somewhere in-between. It's routine (and never boring). Often times, I map out my work weeks in advan...
2 comments
Read more

The Best LGBT+ Books for a Successful Pride 2020

Last October I posted The Best LGBTQ Books of 2019 , and this year is no different. But this year, I want the scope expanded. Included in this year are books only publish in 2020. I also included books for all ages (middle grades through adult contemporary). I hope this list is helpful to you. Remember, the absence of voices is harmful to your students and you. It's important we grow during this tumultuous time. Read these stories! I've enjoyed every one of them, and they're worthy of your consideration. Happy Pride month! Felix Ever After  by Kacen Callender You will see, there's a running theme this year. More books are not only exploring LGBT themes, but also exploring the spectrum outside of the binary. Felix knows their trans. They know they were born biologically female and transitioned to male. But Felix even feels outside that spectrum. When someone puts up a mural of Felix from when they pre-transitioned and dead-names them, Felix seeks revenge through cat-fish...
Post a Comment
Read more

Diversify Your Anti-Racist Readings

When I say Anti-Racist books, what do you think? Does you mind go to Ibram X. Kendi's How to Be An Antiracist  or Tiffany Jewell's This Book is Anti-Racist . Great! What else? Anti-Racist texts are topping the charts of every best seller list. Take a look at the New York Times  Combined Print & E-Book Non-Fiction chart for the week of 6/22/20. This is a wonderful first step. Anti-racist texts occupy nine out of the 10 best selling books. But as educators (or even people just reading this random blog post from an ELA teacher in Chappaqua), is that enough?  Short answer: No.  Taking a look at the Combined Print & E-Book Fiction chart for the same week, and you'll see the problem. Anti-racist fiction is largely ignored. This is a problem. It needs fixing. Only two books on here are what I would categorize anti-racist. What's happening to our anti-racist fiction?  1. Are black writers not writing?  2. Are white publishe...
Post a Comment
Read more